A sermon on Joshua 24:1-3a, 14-25 & 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18 by Nathan Nettleton
A video recording of the whole liturgy, including this sermon, is available here.
Jesus’s name in Hebrew was Joshua, so you would think that he might have been drawn to the book of Joshua, but it is one of the few that he never quotes. It’s not my favourite either, but here we are tonight in Shechem listening to Joshua rallying the people one more time at the end of his life.
This final speech is remembered for perhaps the best line in the whole book: “if you are unwilling to serve the Lord, choose this day whom you will serve, whether the gods your ancestors served before we got here, or the gods you have encountered since we got here; but as for me and my household, we will serve the Lord.”
He’s evoking a memory that was specific to the location. It was here at Shechem that Jacob had buried his idols and chosen to serve the Lord. And as the people respond to Joshua’s speech by declaring their allegiance to the Lord, Joshua twice pushes back, making it clear that this is about more than who they will serve; it is about who they will refuse to serve. People can and do make a display of proclaiming their allegiance to God, while still bending the knee to various other powers.
Serving the Lord means refusing to serve other gods. It is the same kind of radical commitment that was expressed in the 1934 Barmen declaration of the Confessing Church in Germany in the face of the rise of Nazism – Jesus alone is worthy of our unconditional allegiance, therefore we will not give it to any führer.
Joshua’s two categories of false gods – those your ancestors served, and those of the new land – might help us identify some of the idols we are called to refuse to serve in our day. In the first category are the idols we’ve inherited; the ones that have been served by so many for so long that they have acquired a veneer of establishment respectability. But when properly held up to the light of Christ, they can be seen to be anti-Christs.
The God who Jesus makes known to us is passionately committed to the life, well-being and dignity of each and every person, and so would never sacrifice anyone in service of the institutions of church or state. Caiaphas unmasked himself as the leader of an idolatrous cult when, rather than halt the conspiracy against Jesus, he endorsed it, saying “better to have one man die… than to have the whole nation destroyed.” (John 11:50)
Nationalism is one of the most widely practiced idolatries that we’ve inherited from our forebears. As soon as we start giving unquestioning allegiance to our nation – my country, right or wrong – we are treading close to 1934 Germany. Today’s so-called Christian nationalism is the same thing, an idolatrous claim that the current political and cultural values of a nation are God’s values.
Have you noticed how often politicians and commentators evoke the concept of “Australian values” as though they are self-evidently the best values in the world? But if you stand up and say, “Well actually, Australian values seem to include a presumed entitlement to live on stolen land and impose a cone of silence over any discussion of the ongoing impact of the genocidal violence with which that land was stolen,” you can expect to be met by a frenzied outrage calling for you to be burned at the stake for heresy.
Joshua himself is an unwitting example of this, and some of his words that were skipped over in our reading could be speaking of contemporary Australia’s blind spots:
You possess “a land on which you had not laboured, and towns that you had not built, and you live in them; you eat the fruit of crops that you did not plant.” (Joshua 24:13)
Despite having himself led the extremely violent invasion and occupation of the land, Joshua now portrays this possession as a gift given by God – a move that nearly every colonialist conquest in history has used to justify its dispossession of people it regarded as inferior and therefore as expendable. And of course, now that we are in possession of the land, we believe ourselves entitled to pick and choose who else can come.
If we are to stand instead with the one whom Caiaphas said should die for the benefit of the nation, we will learn to look critically at these inherited idolatries through the eyes of those who are being sacrificed to uphold them. We will sit with and listen to those whose lands were stolen to make way for us, to those to whom the borders are closed and who have nowhere else to go. And on Remembrance Day this week, perhaps we can sit with the memory of those who were sent off to wars they barely understood and sacrificed to the cause of nation and empire. We will stand with those victims and say, “No! We choose the way of Jesus.”
Nationalism and the sense of superiority and entitlement that come with it are not the only idols we have inherited from our ancestors. The worship of Mammon goes back far enough that Jesus openly critiqued it: “You cannot serve God and wealth.” That verb “to serve” is the exact same word that Joshua used – “choose whom you will serve.” Jesus and Joshua might not often be on the same page, but they are here. It’s one or the other.
The God who Jesus makes known to us creates an economy of abundance where even the lilies of the field are clothed in splendour and the earth brings forth more than enough for everyone to thrive. But Mammon has other ideas. Don’t make the mistake of thinking that Mammon is just money; Mammon is a master, an imperious idol demanding our unquestioning allegiance. Mammon creates an economy of scarcity, and pits us against one another as rivals, each desiring what the other desires, and willing to serve the machine that promises to produce what we have been deceived into believing we need.
And Mammon thrives on stolen land, stolen wages, and closed borders. That’s why it readily funds the violence of empire that I spoke about a few minutes ago, and drains the earth’s resources to do it. Every idol feeds on sacrificial victims, and Mammon’s victims are not only the world’s poor who are knocking at the borders. It is already feeding on coming generations, the very ones to whom tonight’s psalm said we should be passing on good news, not scorched earth.
If we are to stand with those victims and resist the suicidal and ecocidal demands of Mammon, we are going to have to discover and celebrate the beauty of “enough”. We will need to rediscover the joy of generosity, of sharing, of open-hearted hospitality. We will need to defy the marketers who twist our natural desires into greedy hoarding and competitive possessing. We will say, “No! We choose the way of Jesus.”
Those who crossed the river with Joshua were soon enamoured of new gods in the land, and there are new gods similarly popping up in our contexts, opposing the way of Jesus and consuming countless victims.
The God who Jesus makes known to us is a God who enters fully into the pain and brokenness and anxiety of the world, experiencing its worst without looking away, and without seeking to escape into oblivion or distraction.
In contrast, many are now in thrall to a new god of mesmerising distractions that offer to shield us from pain and fear by keeping us constantly hyper-stimulated and entertained with feel-good meaninglessness. There’s a denial of the realities of a world falling apart that often ends up beyond denial, through numbness, and on to outright oblivion.
This false god has a more respectable and hopeful-sounding cousin called techno-optimism, which cloaks its denial of frightening realities in an unquestioning faith that clever people will invent things that will rescue the planet and its occupants.
I used to think that anything that threatened the Great Barrier Reef would be the final straw that roused the Australian public from their slumber, but most of us now give more time to watching Facebook reels than doing anything about the threats that are killing the reef, drowning whole island nations, and sending anxiety disorders among our young people into the stratosphere.
Jesus calls us to choose instead to follow him in the path of incarnation, of becoming consciously and bodily present to the reality of the world’s pain and predicament. He calls us to follow him in neither denying that reality, nor being paralysed by it, but committing to live fully and generously and beautifully in the midst of it. When we are tempted with offers of denial and escape, we say, “No! We choose the way of Jesus.”
Another of the voracious new gods in the land we have arrived in is probably particularly seductive and dangerous to a group like us.
The God who Jesus makes known to us is a God who sits down at table with outcasts and insiders, friends and opponents alike, offering welcome and acceptance equally. This is a God whose mercy is offered abundantly to all, not overlooking wounds that have been caused, but offering a path of forgiveness and healing that allows both victims and perpetrators to be set free from the chains of spiralling retribution that have bound them both.
But there is a new idolatry stalking the land that particularly preys on those of us who have sought to take sides with the world’s victims, and found our language for it in progressive politics and theology. Now though, when this false god gets its claws into us, our concern for the victims is mutated into a self-righteous and contemptuous hostility that first targets the known perpetrators but soon turns on even those who might have been allies but who somehow fell behind in the arms race for ideological purity.
A word or phrase that last week could be worn as a badge of belonging to those who cared is this week proof that you are an unevolved dinosaur who must be cast into the outer darkness. Concern for victims mutates to become the fuel for a new culture of persecution.
I spoke earlier about the false god of nationalism, and of course, the devotees of this god and that one hate each other with a frenzied passion, precisely because they are mirror images of each other, both obsessed with a purity that excludes the other. They probably even need each other as enemies to know who they are, but the quest for ethno-national purity and the quest for ideological purity are both voracious idolatries that devour victims in great numbers and leave entire communities huddled in fearful silence, terrified of being noticed for any indiscretion that might see them singled out as the next victim.
The ways that we can resist this false god are many, but most of them begin with a willingness to sit down and listen to those we might have been tempted to demonise and shun. One remarkable example is an African American blues musician named Daryl Davis, who for decades has deliberately sought out conversations with Ku Klux Klan members. He would start by asking, “How can you hate me if you don’t even know me?” and then allow a conversation and eventually a friendship to develop from there.
Apparently those friendships led quite a few to quit the Klan, and some gave him their robes when they quit. Even so, he copped criticism from some who thought anything other than naked hostility to klansmen breached the purity code.
Daryl Davis’ approach is not for everyone, and I wouldn’t even encourage it for most victims of hate crimes, but Joshua’s call to choose is addressed to you plural, not you individually. So maybe when you have been the victim, it is me who needs to go and sit down with the perpetrator until they are ready to hand over the robes that mask their violence. It is us as a community who are called to say No to the false gods of purity culture and choose the way of Jesus instead.
Many of the false gods of the ancient world were perhaps easier to recognise than today’s ones because they were much more visible and tangible. Kings and emperors would proclaim themselves to be gods and demand that the people come out to cheer and bow down as they arrived. You either did or you didn’t and everyone could see.
The story of the crowds coming out to cheer Jesus as he rode into Jerusalem on a donkey is a deliberate subversion of that picture of the crowds coming out to greet a king. And there was possibly another one in our reading from Paul’s letter to the Thessalonians. It depicted the final coming of Christ, descending from heaven, and us rising up to meet him. Paul says that the dead in Christ will rise first, which sounds a lot like that great multitude of victims we met last Sunday in the book of Revelation. So the dead victims go first, but then, says Paul, we who are alive will rise up together with them to meet the Lord in the air.
And just like that palm procession image, the one whose arrival we greet is not a conquering ruler back from invading and subjugating foreign lands, but a donkey-riding, crucified victim. And rather than being a mass escape from the world, the procession image is of the coming Christ being welcomed into the city, into the world, which is now his world where heaven makes its home.
So Joshua’s call to choose our god is not a private, spiritual toss-up. It is a call to us, as a community, to stand up and say, “Whoever others may choose to serve, be it the gods our ancestors served or the new gods of our present land, we will refuse those gods and instead arise and go out to welcome the crucified Christ into our lives, our cities, our world.”