A sermon on Matthew 25:14-30 & 1 Thessalonians 5:1-11 by Nathan Nettleton
A video recording of the whole liturgy, including this sermon, is available here.
I don’t think my decision to preach on the Joshua reading last week went very well – I haven’t heard a word of comment or discussion about what I did preach, but I have heard several people say they’d been hoping I was going to preach on the strange parable Jesus told about the ten bridesmaids. Sorry to have disappointed you!
This week I am going to preach on the next parable. Sorry to anyone hoping for Judges! It’s another strange parable, but a lot better known, and Matthew places it as the middle of a set of three parables – immediately after last week’s bridesmaids and immediately before the judgement of the sheep and the goats which we will hear next Sunday.
This middle one, usually known as the parable of the talents, can legitimately and convincingly be read in two entirely different ways. And to complicate that, its link to the parable of the bridesmaids better supports one interpretation, and its link to the sheep and the goats better supports the other. All of which is a good reminder that it is a parable, and parables, unlike allegories, don’t usually have a simple set of this-stands-for-that messages. Instead, they are playful and provocative and a bit mysterious, and invite us to imagine the world in various unexpected ways.
In the more conventional of the two main interpretations, the master who gave the talents represents God, and the three slaves are us, and it’s all about what we do with what we are given. I took that approach last time, but tonight I’m going to turn the parable upside-down and read it the other way. I’m not renouncing my previous sermon. We’re dealing with a parable; there’s no one answer or angle.
So, let’s recap the story and you can judge whether there is any merit to what I’m doing. The scholars are divided; many agree that this upside-down reading is absolutely justified for Luke’s version of the parable, but are a bit more doubtful on this version.
Anyway, what we’ve got is a master going on a long journey and leaving “talents” with his three slaves to trade with. In English the word “talents” can mean our personal gifts and abilities, so we often spiritualise this to talk about how we employ our gifts. That’s not inappropriate, but in the language Jesus spoke, a talent was just an obscenely large unit of money. One talent was about 20 years’ wages for an ordinary worker, and that was the least amount he gave. Between the three, he distributes what amounts to about 160 years’ worth of wages. So this is a story about a billionaire businessman and how he expects his money to be employed.
Two of the slaves meet his expectations, turning big profits. The third one doesn’t so much fail as refuse even to try. Instead, he calls him out, saying, “You are a harsh man, reaping where you do not sow, and gathering where you do not scatter seed.” And interestingly, the master doesn’t even reject that critique; he shrugs it off. Meh.
So the first reason we might want to think about turning this parable upside-down is that a harsh billionaire who profits hugely by exploiting the labour of others and couldn’t care less doesn’t actually sound anything like the way Jesus usually wants us to think about God.
Neither does his next move of taking money from those with the least to further enrich those who already have too much. And notice that line about “to those who have, more will be given”? Jesus does say that elsewhere, but it wasn’t about money, and here it is not Jesus’s commentary on the parable, it is the words of the billionaire in the parable.
Immediately after this parable about the rich getting richer at the expense of the poor, we will go straight on to the parable that asks, “When I was hungry did you feed me? When I was homeless, did you shelter me?”
Well, it’s all very well to say there are some reasons to try reading this parable upside-down, but what happens when we do? If it is not about how we should use our gifts for maximum benefit, what could it be about instead?
Maybe it is just provoking us to think about the way the world is. We now live in a world that’s become obsessed with the lives of billionaires, and if they get caught out having affairs with alleged Chinese spies, sending share prices into a nosedive, well, how entertaining is that?
What’s more important, and it may have escaped our attention while enjoying the circus, is just how much we’ve absorbed their values and expectations, and reshaped our worldview accordingly. Increasing productivity is now regarded as self-evidently a good thing. Economic growth is self-evidently a good thing, and is even talked about at times in reverent tones as “unlimited” economic growth, as though limits were a bad thing. About the only thing in nature that does unlimited growth is cancer.
All of that is reflected in this parable, and part of what we can see is how this growth imperative, once we have given ourselves over to it, begins to talk about itself in moral terms, even in religious terms. The master in the parable welcomes the most profitable servant “into his joy.” He commends the mega-profits with the words, “Well done, good and faithful servant.” The fact that we mostly hear that line in eulogies at funerals, probably without realising where it comes from, is a clear indication that the billionaire’s affirmation has shaped the ways we describe a good and worthwhile life. Growth is called faithfulness. The person who won’t pursue growth is called wicked and lazy. Productivity has been made into a virtue and refusing it made into a sin.
Despite all the hand-wringing going on at the COP summit this week about the way we have sailed right on past the 1.5 degrees of global warming we committed ourselves to avoiding, the fervent religious cult of productivity and growth keeps insisting that we accept without question that the very things that are destroying the planet are what good, right-thinking, responsible people do. You produce more. You consume more. You exploit more. “Well done, good and faithful servant.”
The system keeps promising that if we all play along, everything will work out right. Clever people will invent solutions to our problems just in the nick of time, and all will be well. There will be peace and security for all. But in our other reading tonight, the Apostle Paul warned us against drinking the Kool-Aid: “When they say, ‘There is peace and security,’ then sudden destruction will come upon them, and there will be no escape!”
Read this way around, the third slave, the one who resists the system and unmasks it, becomes the hero of the story. The two so-called “faithful” slaves model themselves on their billionaire master, and show themselves capable of imitating him very successfully. And for their success, the system rewards them handsomely.
But the system seldom rewards a whistle-blower who breaks ranks and names the truth of what is really going on and who is really being screwed. The third slave who resisted the demand for productivity and growth, and spoke out against the harshness of the system, was denounced as worthless, and “thrown into the outer darkness, where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth.” A system that turns itself into a religion will always expel anyone who seeks to call it into question.
And indeed, not long after telling this story, Jesus, the one who is later described as “taking the form of a slave” as he comes among us (Philippians 2:7), is himself denounced as worthless and thrown into the outer darkness of rejection, humiliation, and public execution. So surely it is not so far-fetched to imagine that the non-conformist slave might be the Jesus figure in this parable, unmasking the idols, exposing the lies, and paying a terrible price in his own body.
The call to follow Jesus and resist the demands of the current system certainly does not come with a promise of popularity and economic rewards. When Jesus calls us to take up our own cross and follow him, he is clearly warning us that the more fully we do that, the more we too can expect to find ourselves denounced, expelled, and consigned to the place of weeping and gnashing of teeth. “Follow me anyway,” he says.
I don’t know about you, but I’m not copping much weeping and gnashing of teeth. Not because Jesus was wrong about this, but because I’m so thoroughly compromised. The system has not found me to be enough of a threat to bother expelling me, because I live within it, and do okay from it, and my opposition to it is usually little more than words.
But before I despair of my own hypocrisy and write myself off as being just a less successful version of the first two slaves, it’s worth noting that this parable doesn’t put anyone, even the third slave, on any kind of moral high ground. He might have found the courage to resist and denounce the system, but he was already inside the system, living as part of it. That’s usually the most painful thing for whistle-blowers. They are exposing a system that they themselves are caught up in and have been complicit in.
When Usman Khawaja made the news last week for blowing the whistle and alleging that the great Sandpapergate cricket scandal of 2018 involved a lot more people than just the three who were punished, he had to do it by putting his own hand up and naming himself as one of those who had been complicit. He was claiming that those three had been made scapegoats so that he and the rest of the team could continue to present as having clean hands. And surprise, surprise, admitting to having benefitted from it hasn’t made the system’s backlash against him any gentler. More weeping and gnashing of teeth lie ahead.
None of us here are ever likely to have 160 years’ worth of wages to invest with gay abandon, but we all live inside the dominant economic system and participate in it one way or another. Some are predominantly exploited by it, as sources of labour to grease the wheels that produce profit for other people. But in this privileged country, even ordinary workers have superannuation accounts, and those funds are all administered on our behalf by sharp investors whose job it is to ensure the profitable growth of our super funds.
I make myself feel better by choosing the ethical investment options that my super fund offers, but if I’m honest about it, such options are probably just better-mannered versions of the first two slaves of our parable. Sometimes they generate bigger returns than the standard options. “Well done, good and faithful servant.”
Jesus’s own ministry was supported by a number of wealthy benefactors, many of them women. Even for him, there was no way to come and live among us that didn’t mean living in and by the system to some extent. Perhaps when the Bible talks of him “becoming sin for our sakes” (2 Cor 5:21), that’s part of what it is getting at – he joined us in the life we live, entangled as we are in webs of systemic sin.
None of us know how to extricate ourselves from the systems we are immersed in. But the upside-down reading of this parable doesn’t really even suggest that we can make some sort of successful escape into a place of purity. The third slave resists the system, but only from his place inside it. His first act of resistance is simply truth-telling, speaking up about the truth of what the system is and what it is doing to other people and to the planet, speaking truth to power.
At first glance, that may not seem like all that much. But in practice, it is pretty scary, because the system tolerates no dissent. The whistle-blower slave admits to being afraid of the master, afraid of the consequences of speaking out, and his fears prove to be well founded. But to his credit, he acts anyway.
Next week’s parable sees Jesus returning dignity to those who the system has expelled or chewed up and spat out. Perhaps, after speaking up, the next step of resistance is just to refuse to accept the verdict of “lazy and worthless” that the champions of the system want to pass on those who refuse to participate in the all-consuming worship of growth.
Our Thessalonians reading warns us of the hostility and conflict we are likely to face when we stand for light and truth in the face of darkness and lies. You will need to be sober, awake, alert, and dressed in armour, it says – “a breastplate of faith and love, and for a helmet the hope of salvation.” There’s no mention there of arming ourselves with weapons of attack, but there is acknowledgement we will likely need some protection from them ourselves.
And ultimately, it ends on a reminder that resisting the system is best done together. “Therefore encourage one another and build up each other, as indeed you are doing,” says Paul. If a whistle needs blowing, don’t let being alone stop you, but if others rightly identify what needs to be spoken out about first, stand with them, encouraging one another and building each other up.
Commenting on the Usman Khawaja story this week, one journalist quipped that so many people had been said to have been thrown under the bus that by the end of the week, “there is not a member of the Australian cricket team who does not reside beneath a bus.” What the news pictures as beneath a bus, the biblical stories picture as the place of weeping and gnashing of teeth. Whatever we call it, and whyever we were thrown there, if we can begin encouraging one another down there to speak and live the truth that is perhaps even more clearly seen from there, it just might be the place from which the change the world desperately needs begins.